← All articles

Are We Looking for the Truth, or Just Evidence That We’re Right?

We can collect plenty of evidence and still miss the bigger picture. A reflection on how confirmation bias shapes our judgments, relationships and decisions.

7–10 minutes
Three people watching the same film in a cinema respond differently: one leans forward, one smiles quietly and another looks unconvinced.

Listen to this article · 9 min

After a disagreement with a friend, my wife or my mother, I sometimes find myself replaying the conversation in my head. I remember what the other person said, recall earlier incidents and come up with reasons why my response was justified. Without quite noticing it, I begin building a convincing story in which my interpretation makes perfect sense.

What interests me is how naturally this happens. I am not deliberately trying to ignore the other person’s perspective, yet my mind keeps finding reasons to support my own. Before long, I may become even more convinced that I was right, although nothing new has actually happened.

I have been trying to recognise this pattern and pause when I notice it. It helps me consider whether the other person might have seen something I missed. I may still disagree, but I become more open to the possibility that my version is not the only reasonable one.

I wonder how often we do something similar in everyday life. Are we genuinely trying to understand what is happening, or are we sometimes gathering evidence to support what we already believe?

We Often Find What We Expect

Suppose you have almost decided to buy a particular car. You like its features and have started imagining yourself driving it. When you read reviews, praise feels convincing, while complaints seem like unusual exceptions. You may have chosen an excellent car, but are you evaluating both kinds of information with the same care?

Psychologists call this tendency confirmation bias. Our existing beliefs can influence what we notice, how we interpret information and what we remember. The difficult part is that we may sincerely believe we are being objective while giving greater importance to evidence that agrees with us.

Imagine watching a movie after hearing several people say it is overrated. You begin watching with that expectation. Whenever a scene feels boring or a performance disappoints, it reinforces what you already believe. But when you enjoy a scene or appreciate an actor’s performance, you might dismiss it as an exception.

The movie may genuinely have weaknesses. But have you evaluated it fairly, or have you been paying more attention to the parts that confirm what you expected? Something similar can happen with more important beliefs. We may have plenty of genuine examples supporting our opinion while overlooking other examples that tell a different story.

When We Start Seeing Only Someone’s Weaknesses

I have a friend who frequently talks about his manager’s shortcomings. Some complaints may be justified, but I wonder whether he gives enough weight to the things the manager has done well, including giving him a job when he was unemployed.

Being grateful for an opportunity does not mean accepting poor treatment or ignoring genuine problems. But if we have already decided someone is a poor manager, we may begin interpreting almost everything they do through that belief. Their mistakes become further proof, while their positive actions receive less attention.

I have noticed something similar with a couple I know. The husband often finds fault with his wife, even when she tries to improve things. She appears to do the same with him. I cannot know everything happening in their relationship, but I wonder how difficult it becomes to recognise someone’s efforts when we are already convinced of their shortcomings.

A negative experience can sometimes overshadow several positive ones, especially when disappointment has accumulated over time. But the reverse can happen too. When we admire someone, we may excuse their mistakes and overlook their weaknesses.

Perhaps the problem is not simply whether our opinion is positive or negative. It is how easily that opinion can become the filter through which we interpret everything that follows.

We May Be Right and Still Be Unfair

This is what I find particularly interesting about confirmation bias. Our conclusion may actually be correct, yet the way we reached it may still have been selective.

When information supports our opinion, we may accept it quite easily. When it challenges us, we suddenly ask tougher questions. Is the source reliable? Could the example be unusual? What else might explain it?

These are good questions, but we should ask them about evidence we agree with too. Otherwise, we are applying different standards depending on whether we like the answer.

Experience and intelligence do not automatically protect us from this tendency. Sometimes they simply help us construct more convincing explanations for what we already believe.

Our Digital World Makes It Easier

Imagine receiving a WhatsApp message supporting something you strongly believe. You find it convincing and perhaps share it with friends. When another message challenges your opinion, you examine it more critically.

Online searches can work similarly. Someone convinced that a particular diet is beneficial may search for its advantages, while someone worried about it searches for its risks. Both may find genuine information and finish more confident in their original opinions.

Social media can reinforce this further. When several people agree with a claim, it may feel more trustworthy. But ten people sharing the same message do not necessarily provide ten independent pieces of evidence. They might all be repeating something from the same unverified source.

AI can be used in the same way. Ask a chatbot why your preferred decision makes sense and it may generate a convincing explanation. Ask it to examine the strongest reasons against that decision and you may discover concerns you hadn’t considered. Both answers still need to be evaluated, but the questions we ask can influence what we receive.

Even Our Memories Can Support Our Beliefs

Imagine a parent who believes their teenager is always distracted by a phone. Every delayed response or unfinished task becomes another example supporting that opinion. But the parent may overlook occasions when the child completed their work, helped at home or used the phone responsibly.

The concern may still be genuine. What matters is whether we are considering the complete pattern or mainly remembering incidents that reinforce our impression.

We can do the same with beliefs about ourselves. Someone who thinks they are poor at public speaking may vividly remember embarrassing presentations while overlooking occasions when they communicated well. Someone convinced they are an excellent leader might remember praise more readily than useful criticism.

Over time, we can become increasingly certain of something without necessarily developing a more accurate understanding of it.

What Would Make Us Reconsider?

I don’t think the answer is to question everything endlessly. We need experience, judgment and reasonable confidence to make decisions. Being open-minded also doesn’t mean treating every opinion as equally credible.

One question I find useful is: What would genuinely make me reconsider what I believe?

If we are convinced that an investment is a good opportunity, we could examine the strongest credible reasons against it. If we believe someone never changes, we could pay attention to whether their behaviour has actually improved.

The same principle can help during disagreements. Instead of mentally collecting more reasons why we are right, we can ask whether there is another explanation that deserves consideration.

We may still reach our original conclusion, and that is perfectly fine. The difference is that we have given ourselves a fair opportunity to understand something we might otherwise have missed.

Pause & reflect

Which Beliefs Might I Be Defending?

  1. After a disagreement, do I mentally collect examples that justify why I was right?
  2. Is there someone whose mistakes I notice more easily than their good qualities or efforts to improve?
  3. Do I question information more critically when it challenges my beliefs than when it supports them?
  4. When was the last time something I learnt genuinely changed my mind?

Something to Try

The next time you notice yourself mentally defending a belief or replaying a disagreement, pause and consider one reasonable alternative explanation. Give it the same attention you give your own perspective, even if you ultimately disagree.

Making Room for Another Perspective

I still catch myself building convincing stories after disagreements. Being aware of this tendency has not made it disappear. But noticing when it begins gives me an opportunity to pause before every remembered incident becomes another argument supporting my version.

Sometimes I may still be right. Sometimes the other person may have misunderstood me. But there may also be something important in their perspective that I haven’t considered.

I think this matters beyond disagreements. When we become convinced that someone is incapable, selfish or unreliable, we may stop noticing evidence that they are changing. When we become certain about ourselves, we may overlook opportunities to learn and grow.

We do not have to abandon our beliefs every time someone disagrees with us. But perhaps we should be careful about becoming so attached to being right that we stop being curious about what might also be true.

After all, what is the point of trying to understand something if we are unwilling to discover that we may have been mistaken?

Share

Browse all articles →

About Sairam

Sairam Dharmaraju

Former business leader, now a writer, coach and mentor exploring how we can live and work better across work, wellbeing, purpose, relationships and life choices.


Leave a Comment