Listen to this article · 8 min
During an argument, I have sometimes been completely convinced that what I was saying was reasonable. I could explain my point, recall earlier incidents and tell myself I was thinking logically. Yet once the frustration settled, I could see that I had given far more attention to what hurt or annoyed me than to what the other person might have meant.
I have noticed a similar pattern when we are happy or excited. An opportunity looks wonderful, and our minds quickly produce reasons to pursue it while the doubts seem less important. We may be reacting on emotional autopilot without noticing it, even as we confidently explain why our decision makes sense.
Perhaps that is the difficult part. Emotions do not always prevent us from reasoning; sometimes they influence which reasons we find convincing. We can feel completely objective even when our feelings are helping shape the conclusion.
We Don’t Always Notice What Influences Us
Our feelings can influence what catches our attention, how we interpret information and which risks or benefits seem important. We might not be ignoring the facts. We may simply be giving some facts more weight than others, without recognising why.
Think about a new project at work. Someone who is excited may notice the possibilities, while a colleague worried about an already heavy workload may focus on what could go wrong. Both could have valid concerns, but neither may be seeing the whole picture. The same can happen when affection makes us overlook someone’s behaviour or optimism makes difficulties appear smaller than they are.
Emotions are not necessarily a problem. They can tell us what matters to us, alert us to unfairness and give us the courage to act. The challenge is recognising their influence rather than assuming our interpretation is the complete picture.
Sometimes We Find Reasons for What We Already Believe
Sometimes we begin with a conclusion we want to believe and then search for reasons that support it. Psychologists describe this as one form of motivated reasoning. Our arguments may sound sensible, but the way we evaluate information can already be tilted towards the answer we prefer.
I often notice this in major financial decisions. Owning a house can represent security, achievement and the feeling that we have finally settled down. I personally question taking a large home loan when we could not afford to buy the property outright, although that is my preference, not a universal financial rule. A loan can make sense for some families. What interests me is whether the emotional desire to own a home sometimes comes before a careful examination of affordability, alternatives and trade-offs.
Something similar can happen when parents want to send their children abroad for higher education, even when it would put considerable pressure on family finances. The hope of a better future is understandable, and the opportunities may be real. But aspirations, pride or social expectations might make it harder to weigh the sacrifices fairly. Equally, fear of spending money could make us undervalue a worthwhile opportunity.
Our ego can also influence how we argue. When someone questions a decision we have made, it can feel like a criticism of our intelligence or judgment. Instead of asking whether the criticism is useful, we start defending ourselves. We can use logic to examine a belief, but we can also use logic to defend a belief we are emotionally attached to.
The Same Situation Can Feel Different on Another Day
Not every emotion influences us in the same way. Some experiments suggest that fear and anger can affect risk judgments differently, although the findings are not universal. More simply, most of us know that an issue can feel different depending on our mood.
After a frustrating day, an ordinary remark at home may sound insulting. We respond as though the remark alone caused our irritation, overlooking what we carried into the conversation. On a calmer day, the same words might barely bother us.
I have also noticed how a decision made in anger can appear less sensible once the emotion settles. A strongly worded message may seem completely justified at night and unnecessary the next morning. Waiting is not always right, particularly when something requires urgent attention, but sometimes a little time helps us see what our first reaction missed.
The Perspectives We Don’t Realise We’re Missing
Imagine a manager who is already frustrated with an employee. The next missed deadline becomes more evidence that the employee is unreliable. Yet the delay might have depended on another team, or the employee might have raised a concern worth hearing. The manager may still be right, but frustration could have influenced which facts received attention.
In a disagreement with someone close to us, we know how their words affected us and why we responded as we did. What we may not know is everything the other person was dealing with or what they intended. Our wish to be understood can become so strong that we stop trying to understand them.
Feeling certain is not the same as having sufficient evidence. Being open to another perspective does not mean excusing unfair behaviour or accepting every explanation. It means allowing relevant information to challenge a conclusion before deciding we have understood the whole story.
Thinking More Doesn’t Always Mean Thinking Better
We can spend hours analysing a decision and keep returning to the same concerns. We can discuss a disagreement with friends who agree with us and become even more convinced we are right. Gathering more arguments does not necessarily mean we have considered more possibilities.
Sometimes we are genuinely thinking carefully. At other times, we may simply be getting better at defending what we already believe. Good reasoning requires not only asking why our conclusion makes sense, but also what might make it incomplete.
I find myself returning to a few uncomfortable questions. Would I judge the situation differently if I liked the person involved? What evidence would make me change my mind? Am I reacting to what happened, or to what I believe it means?
Thinking Clearly Without Ignoring Our Feelings
I don’t think we need to choose between emotions and logic. A useful starting point may be to notice what we are feeling before becoming too attached to a conclusion. Am I afraid, angry, excited, disappointed or proud? Could that feeling be influencing what I notice and what I dismiss?
We can also separate the event from our interpretation of it. Someone disagreeing with us is something that happened; concluding that they do not respect us is one possible explanation. Before making an important decision, we might ask what information is missing and what consequences we would still accept if things turned out differently.
This is not an invitation to doubt ourselves endlessly. Sometimes the facts are clear and our feelings are justified. The aim is not to suppress emotions or give every perspective equal weight, but to make room for anything important that our feelings might have led us to overlook.
Pause & reflect
What Might Be Influencing My Thinking?
- Can I recall a decision where my feelings influenced what I considered logical?
- Is there someone I judge differently because I already like or dislike them?
- When did I last seriously consider evidence that challenged something I believed?
- Is there a current situation I might see differently if I were less emotionally involved?
Being Logical May Require More Self-Awareness
I still believe in examining facts, listening carefully and considering consequences. But I am increasingly aware that we bring our fears, hopes, experiences and expectations into our reasoning, often without realising it. That doesn’t make our thinking worthless. It makes it human.
Perhaps being logical isn’t about having no emotions. It is about recognising their influence, especially when we feel completely objective. Sometimes the more useful question isn’t whether we have enough reasons to believe we’re right, but whether we have been willing to see what might make us wrong.

Leave a Comment