Listen to the article · 8:45
When my wife tells me about a problem or a dilemma, my first instinct used to be to suggest what she could do. Quite often, she would tell me that she didn’t want advice or solutions. She simply wanted me to listen and understand what she was going through.
Interestingly, we have caught each other doing the same thing, with our roles reversed. Sometimes I want to be heard, and she begins offering suggestions. I’ve noticed this beyond our marriage too, with children, friends, parents and colleagues. Someone shares a problem, and we begin planning their next move before we fully understand it. What we see as concern or helpfulness may feel very different to the person speaking. Why do we do this, often with the best intentions? And how can we recognise whether someone needs a listener, a suggestion or something more practical?
Why Are We So Eager to Offer Solutions?
Most of us offer advice because we care. We don’t like seeing someone struggle, especially when we’ve been through something similar or believe we can help. At work, solving problems is often valued; as parents, we’re used to guiding our children. Over time, responding with a solution can become a habit, even in conversations where no one has asked us to solve anything.
Listening can also be uncomfortable. When someone is worried or upset, offering advice makes us feel that we’re doing something useful. Staying with their uncertainty, without immediately trying to fix it, may feel harder. Research has found that giving advice can increase the adviser’s sense of influence. That doesn’t mean our motives are selfish, but it is worth asking whether our suggestions are meeting the other person’s needs or our own.
Perhaps that also explains why we sometimes feel disappointed when our advice isn’t followed. We set out to help, yet become attached to the solution we proposed. We may even repeat it more firmly, assuming the other person simply hasn’t understood. But the real misunderstanding could be ours.
Are We Listening or Preparing Our Reply?
Sometimes, a friend calls me to explain how difficult things have become at work. Before they’ve even finished, I find myself wanting to suggest a different approach or offer ideas on how to handle specific problems. The suggestions might be sensible, but perhaps they’ve already considered them and simply want to talk about an exhausting week.
I’ve noticed something similar as a parent. When my daughter has been disappointed with her examination results, I’ve sometimes responded with an immediate lecture about studying harder. But I soon realised that she may already know what went wrong and might need encouragement before discussing how to improve. In both situations, I was so focused on helping that I hadn’t fully understood what the other person needed. Sometimes people already know their options. What they’re finding difficult is accepting a disappointment, making a choice or dealing with uncertainty.
Sometimes we appear to be listening while mentally preparing our response. We interrupt, finish sentences, glance at our phone or turn the conversation towards a similar experience of our own. Attentive listening means following what someone says, noticing what we haven’t understood and asking questions that help them explain. Research on conversations suggests that relevant follow-up questions can make people feel heard and understood. A question such as “What’s worrying you the most?” may reveal more than a well-intentioned suggestion offered too soon. And sometimes, explaining a problem helps the person make sense of it themselves.
When Good Advice Doesn’t Feel Helpful
Imagine finally sharing a problem you’ve worried about for days and immediately hearing what you should have done differently. Even correct advice can feel like criticism if the person offering it hasn’t understood the circumstances. “Just change jobs” or “stop worrying about what others think” may overlook responsibilities, fears and choices that aren’t visible from outside.
Research suggests that unsolicited advice is often received less favourably when the person isn’t open to it. Repeated suggestions can make someone feel that we doubt their ability to decide for themselves, leaving them defending their choices instead of exploring them. The problem isn’t necessarily the advice itself; it may be the timing, the assumptions behind it or the way it is offered, even when our intentions are good.
Sometimes They Need Help, Not Suggestions
Consider an employee who tells a manager they’re overwhelmed. The manager immediately recommends better time management. But what if the real issue is an unrealistic workload or unclear expectations? The manager may be able to change those conditions rather than asking the employee to cope better.
Similarly, someone who has lost a job may appreciate being heard, but also welcome an introduction to a recruiter. Someone caring for an elderly parent may need a few hours of practical assistance more than another suggestion to manage stress. Support isn’t limited to listening or advice; sometimes it means doing something useful. The difference matters especially when the person offering advice has the ability to reduce the problem, not merely comment on it.
Why Is It Harder With People Close to Us?
Listening is especially difficult when we are part of the problem. If our spouse questions a family decision we helped make, we may start defending our reasoning. When a colleague says something we did caused difficulties, our instinct may be to explain ourselves rather than hear their experience.
We may patiently listen to a friend’s problem yet become defensive with someone at home because we have our own feelings and interests in the situation. Understanding another person’s perspective doesn’t mean agreeing with them or abandoning ours. But hearing them fully before presenting our view can change the conversation. If we begin defending ourselves at the first sign of disagreement, the other person may stop explaining what they wanted us to understand.
How Can We Recognise What Someone Needs?
A person may want to express their feelings first, consider options later and ask for practical help after that. On another day, the same person might want advice immediately. We don’t need to treat listening and advising as fixed roles. What helps can change even during one conversation, so an approach that was useful at the beginning may no longer be useful ten minutes later.
Sometimes “That sounds difficult. Tell me what happened” helps someone continue. We might later ask, “Would you like to think through some options together?” or “Is there anything practical I can do?” These aren’t lines to repeat mechanically. They are reminders to check what would help instead of assuming we know. Close relationships may make these signals easier to notice, but familiarity doesn’t guarantee that we have understood them correctly.
Listening doesn’t mean agreeing with everything or avoiding uncomfortable truths. Relevant advice can be valuable when someone asks for it, and a serious safety concern may require immediate action. Nor must we remain available for endless conversations. Repeatedly revisiting problems without progress can be draining. Research on excessive problem-focused discussion, especially among young friends, has found associations with greater distress, though that doesn’t mean talking about problems is harmful. Support sometimes means setting a boundary or gently helping the conversation move forward. The difference is whether we’re helping people understand their choices or trying to make those choices for them.
Pause & reflect
When Do You Offer Advice Before Listening?
- When someone shares a problem, do you listen to understand or begin preparing your advice?
- Have you ever received advice when all you wanted was to be heard? How did it feel?
- When you offer suggestions, how often do you check whether the other person wants them?
- Is someone close to you more likely to need your attention, a different perspective or practical help?
Sometimes Being Heard Matters Most
I still believe thoughtful advice and shared experience can help. But I’m learning that someone telling me about a problem isn’t necessarily asking me to solve it. They may need understanding first, a different perspective later or help with something I can actually do.
Perhaps the next time someone opens up to us, we could resist the immediate urge to offer an answer and try to understand what would genuinely help. Sometimes being present is more valuable than having a solution.

Leave a Comment